How to Tell If Matcha Is Good: Colour, Aroma and Taste

Have you ever wondered what makes that vibrant green cup of matcha so special?
You can spot a good matcha before you even taste it: it is a vivid green, it smells of freshly cut grass and, once whisked, it tastes sweet and savoury with a gentle bitterness. A poor matcha is yellowish or olive green, smells of hay and tastes harsh. This is a tasting guide to telling them apart at home, with what to look for, smell and taste.
If what you want to know is what matcha is, how it is grown and what its grades mean, start with our guide what is matcha? Here it is all about the cup.
The four signs of a quality matcha
| Sign | Quality matcha | Poor or stale matcha |
|---|---|---|
| Colour of the powder | Deep, bright green | Yellowish, olive or brownish green |
| Aroma | Fresh grass, vegetal and sweet | Hay, dust or barely any smell |
| Texture | Very fine, silky powder that clings to your fingers | Grainy or coarse |
| Flavour | Umami, sweetness and a soft bitterness at the end | Bitter, astringent and flat |
Why does the colour tell you so much?
Matcha's green is chlorophyll. When the plant is grown in shade for the weeks before harvest, it produces more chlorophyll and the powder comes out an electric green. Over time, with light and air, the chlorophyll breaks down and the green turns dull and yellowish. So the colour tells you both how good the leaf was and how fresh the powder is.
A taster's trick: put a pinch on a sheet of white paper and spread it with your finger. A good matcha leaves an even, vivid green smear.
Where does the umami come from?
Matcha's smooth, deep flavour comes largely from L-theanine, an amino acid the leaf builds up when it is grown in shade. In strong sun, some of that L-theanine turns into catechins, which are what give bitterness and astringency. That is why an unshaded matcha, or one made from older leaves from late harvests, tastes more bitter and less sweet.
How to hold a tasting at home
- Look at the powder in natural light and, if you can, compare it with another matcha.
- Smell it as soon as you open the tin.
- Make an usucha: 2 g of sifted matcha and 70-80 ml of water at 75-80 °C, whisked in a zigzag until frothy.
- Look at the froth: a good matcha forms a fine, dense foam with tiny bubbles.
- Taste it on its own, without milk or sugar. Look for sweetness and umami at the start and a short bitterness at the finish.
The full technique, with and without a whisk, is in our step-by-step guide to making matcha. And if your cup turns out bitter even though the matcha is good, check the most common mistakes when making matcha: it is almost always water that is too hot.
And when you mix it with milk?
With milk or a plant-based drink, the bitterness softens and the differences are harder to notice, which is why it is best always to taste with water. For an everyday latte you do not need the most expensive matcha, but you do need one that is fresh and brightly coloured.
How to store it so it keeps its colour
- A tightly closed tin, away from light, heat and strong smells.
- Once opened, it is best used within a few weeks.
- Always use a dry spoon: moisture makes it clump and speeds up oxidation.
Our matcha
Our Japanese Matcha Premium is 100% Japanese matcha from Kagoshima, shade-grown and stone-ground; we tell its story in from the Sakurajima volcano to your cup. The Green Matcha Blend is Japanese matcha blended with chlorella and spinach, and it is the only one of our colour blends that contains matcha.
Keep reading
- How much caffeine is in matcha, product by product
- The matcha ritual: its history and how to prepare it step by step
- Matcha vs hojicha: differences in flavour, colour and caffeine
- The origins and evolution of powdered tea in Asia
Try it at home
The products mentioned in this article: Japanese Matcha Premium · Green Matcha Blend